Magpie Murders

Magpie Murders

Book - 2017
Average Rating:
Rate this:
"From New York Times bestselling author Anthony Horowitz comes Magpie Murders, a brilliant and strikingly original reimagining of the classic whodunit (a la Agatha Christie) with a contemporary mystery wrapped around it"-- Provided by publisher
Publisher: New York : Harper, an imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers, 2017
Edition: First U.S. edition
Copyright Date: ©2017
ISBN: 9780062645234
Characteristics: 236 pages ; 24 cm


From Library Staff

I liked the old fashioned Agatha Christie feel of the 1950’s English village murders and the village characters who all had a motive for wanting the two victims dead, and the Poirot-like investigator, Atticus Pünd, a German Auschwitz survivor. But there’s even more to it because this story is pre... Read More »

From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment

DPLcatherine Mar 16, 2018

If you love solving murder mysteries, wouldn’t it be great if your biggest clue was another murder mystery? Metafiction for lovers of traditional mysteries with relatable characters and just enough twists to keep things interesting.

Feb 26, 2018

I enjoyed most of the novel, but the disclaimer at the beginning was unwarranted. When I re-read it after finishing the book, the character did say that it was life-changing for her (which it was), but there was no reason to warn other readers. It certainly didn't stand out as one of the best books I've ever read, and most definitely was not life changing.

Feb 22, 2018

I read this over two days and even then had a difficult time keeping track of all the characters/suspects in two different mysteries; it’s easy to forget why the various characters would be considered suspects and I thought about making notes to refer back to. But instead I made the effort to read through it as quickly as possible. Overall, well-written with two interesting plots.

Feb 15, 2018

A fun throwback to golden-age English mysteries . Book editor Susan sits down to read the manuscript for the latest novel featuring fictional detective Atticus Pund. We read along with her, but as the story speeds along to a climax, Susan discovers that the final pages of the manuscript are missing, Susan's publisher boss has received a suicide letter from author Alan Conway, and he has been found dead. As Susan tries to find the missing manuscript, she begins to suspect Conway may not have ended his own life.

The literary mystery reminds me of A.S Byatt's novel Possession (one of my all-time favorites) as different documents offer clues to Conway's life and possible motives for his death. The plot is highlighted by comedic glimpses into the world of contemporary publishing, including the real life grandson of Agatha Christie as a character, the premise of an author trapped by his own success, and ruminations on whether murder mysteries are literature or junk.

But I found Susan to be a disappointing protagonist. It seemed unbelievable for a book editor to be more interested in her amateur murder investigation than in tracking down the missing manuscript. And the choice she made to resolve her personal life was a letdown.

When we finally do read the once missing pages, the ending to the Atticus Pund mystery is quite clever. I was able to guess both "whodunnits" , but was surprised by additional plot twists related to motive. Though the motive for Alan Conway's murder is a bit silly, it leads to a highly suspenseful climax.

A cautionary note for E-Readers: make sure to begin reading at the "Magpie Murders" title page or at the table of contents. My digital copy loaded and opened at the title page for Alan Conway's manuscript, bypassing the "Crouch End, London" chapter.

Feb 13, 2018

I feel as if this novel should come with a disclaimer. It would go something like this: "Warning, the book you are about to read requires a surplus of long-suffering from its reader." The interruptions are jarring, but the novel is so brilliant I could not rate it anything under 4.5 stars. You have been warned ;)

Jan 28, 2018

This thriller is great if you loved Gone Girl or Girl on the Train. It's about Susan Ryeland who's an editor for a bestselling mystery novel writer. But she soon believes that this may be about real life. What I like about this book is that the main character is an everyman, she's relatable to most of her readers because she doesn't really know what she's doing.
- @Florence of the Teen Review Board of the Hamilton Public Library

Jan 10, 2018

I liked the enveloping story better than the Atticus Pund novel in the center. I never did care much for Agatha Christie and Pund was another in the Hercule Periot mold.

Dec 29, 2017

Anthony Horowitz is definitely in the running for next in succession of the famous British mystery and suspense novel authors of AC Doyle (Sherlock Holmes), Agatha Christie (Hercule Poirot), and Ian Fleming (James Bond) . For mystery fans, this one, a mystery about a mystery book, is a must. The outer novella provides enough clear clues -- hidden amongst red herrings of course -- that if read carefully, it can be solved by the reader. The inner novella, it's not quite so reader solvable. The detective has access to clues the reader doesn't. But even the inner novella, if the logic is carefully followed, the solution of who did it can be narrowed down by the reader to two or three persons from the dozen or so potential candidates. Very much recommended, both in the book form and in the audio book format.

ontherideau Nov 09, 2017

Magpie Murders is a wild merry go round that throws the reader off and then slows down to let us back on. A book within a book and a motive for everyone.

Oct 02, 2017

Susan Ryeland receives the latest whodunit from her top mystery writer without the last chapter or the author. The current mystery in Part 2 is a better read than Alan Conway’s in Part 1, which is riddled with red herrings and 1955 reading Victorian. Save your sleuthing for the fuller characters, and it’s fun and solvable.

View All Comments


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at MARINet

To Top