The Secret Speech

The Secret Speech

Book - 2009
Average Rating:
5
Rate this:
Publisher: New York : Grand Central Pub., 2009
ISBN: 9780446402408
0446402400
Characteristics: 405 p. ; 24 cm

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

s
Sarah1984
May 05, 2016

SPOILERS!! SPOILERS!! SPOILERS!! SPOILERS!!

31/7 - Even more of a page turner than Child 44! I loved this, so much so that I stayed up till 2 am two nights in a row feverishly reading, unable to stop turning the pages until I fell asleep with the book in my hands.

I had forgotten how irritating and occasionally confusing I find Smith's choice of how to format and punctuate his dialogue. Instead of placing his dialogue within a pair of speech marks, as most writers do, Smith has to be different so he italicises his dialogue and neglects the speech marks altogether. Every so often I'd mistake dialogue for internal monologue because italics usually signify internal thoughts. Fortunately the pacing and plot successfully overcome that irritation. I was expecting the rescue of Zoya to be the exciting climax of the book, so I was quite surprised to find I still had over 100 pages to go and it appeared that the story was done with Zoya.

In my review for Child 44 I discussed the hate the book made me feel for Russia/Soviet Russia. I didn't feel the hate for a whole country quite as strongly while reading The Secret Speech. It was more about the individuals this time. I couldn't help but despise the prisoners who tortured Leo. Even though I understood their reasons, after what they did to him I couldn't find any sympathy for their plight. Yes, he did horrific, brutal things to people, but what choice did he have. If Leo hadn't been the torturer, if he had refused, someone else would have happily stepped into his place (as was shown in Child 44 when Leo couldn't continue with one of the interrogations when the doctor was injecting the castor oil into the prisoner) and he and his family would have been taken away to be tortured themselves. When the government is like the government of Soviet Russia was (still is), one man rebelling isn't going to change anything. All that's going to happen is that the torturers will have four more victims (Leo, Raisa, Anna, and Stepan as the whole family, maybe even some unfortunate neighbours, would have been punished for Leo's rebellion), the gulags four more prisoners, if they even made it that far. When the reign of terror is so pervasive all you can do is try to survive and keep your family safe. I'm looking forward the final book in the trilogy.

c
cheadlebeagle
Apr 20, 2015

Not quite as good as Child 44 but still a good read. I'm going to read Agent 6 to finish the trilogy.

g
gloryb
Jan 05, 2014

A page turner!! Takes the reader from the intrigues of communist Moscow to the viciousness of survival in the Gulags to the beginnings of the Hungarian Revolution...all through the main character, Leo, as he tries to consolidate and protect the family he loves. The novel made we want to seek out the nonfiction books recommended by the author in his Acknowledgments. Probably makes more sense to read the trilogy of titles in order.

p
Patricia03
Sep 10, 2011

This book was better than the first although it is a genre based on the West's Cold War view of Russia

p
pshammi
Mar 03, 2011

Great follow up to Child 44, though the detective plot may not be quite as intricate or interesting as the first book, the character development is even stronger with the personal relationships having far greater depth and meaning. Overall, a great read.

Age

Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at MARINet

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top